Best Child Daycare & Preschools in Reynoldsburg, OH
Compare 23 child daycare & preschools in Reynoldsburg. Average rating: 3.88/5 stars. See top 10 ranked daycares, compare by type, and find the right childcare for your family.
Reynoldsburg, Ohio at a glance
- Programs
- 23
- Avg rating
- 3.88/5
- Parent reviews
- 257
- Top rated (4.5+)
- 4
Reynoldsburg has 23 licensed child daycare & preschools with 257 parent reviews averaging 3.88/5.The largest concentration is in 43068 with 32 programs.Start with our top-10 ranked list below or filter by philosophy.
Top 10 Best Rated Daycares in Reynoldsburg
Ranked using a weighted score that combines Google rating with the number of parent reviews — daycares with more reviews rank higher than those with a high rating but few reviews. Last updated: March 2026.
- 1Reynoldsburg United Methodist Preschool4.58 score5(7)
1636 Graham Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: 50 children
Parents consistently praise Reynoldsburg United Methodist Preschool for its caring, dedicated teachers and positive learning environment. Children reportedly make significant academic and social progress while enjoying daily activities and developing enthusiasm for school. Families appreciate the curriculum, family engagement opportunities, and kindergarten preparation.
caring and dedicated teachersacademic improvement (alphabet skillskindergarten readiness)social skill development - 2Messiah Christian School4.39 score4.6(9)
1200 Waggoner Road, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: 88 children
Messiah Christian School receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, with parents praising the caring, dedicated staff and strong educational programs. Most reviewers highlight the school's commitment to individual student needs and faith-based approach. However, one parent reported their child was discharged after only two weeks for behavioral concerns.
Kind and loving teachersgenuine care for childrenstrong academic preparationseamless transitions - 3Capital Royal Child Care & Learning Center4.24 score4.3(20)
1288 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Parents consistently praise Capital Royal Child Care & Learning Center for its safe, nurturing environment and highly attentive staff. The facility is commended for strong communication, specialized care for children with allergies, and comprehensive daily activity monitoring via app. Children reportedly enjoy attending and show academic and social improvement.
Staff compassion and patiencechild safety and security measuresallergy managementdaily communication and photo updates - 4A Child'S Place Learning Center4.21 score4.3(11)
2010 Officeview Place, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
A Child's Place Learning Center receives mostly positive reviews praising the staff's care, educational focus, and child development outcomes. However, two negative reviews raise serious concerns about health/safety protocols, allergy management, staff conduct, and responsiveness to parent instructions.
Educational curriculum with daily learningcompassionate and caring staffclean and safe facilityparental involvement - 5Shining Stars Child Care4.14 score4.2(11)
491 Lancaster Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Shining Stars Child Care receives overwhelmingly positive reviews praising the dedicated staff, caring director (Mrs. Shaton), and play-based educational approach. However, two negative reviews raise concerns about management practices, facility size, staffing decisions, and bus safety.
Caring and dedicated staffpersonable directorplay-based learning modeldaily activity updates via app - 6St Pius X4.12 score4.2(7)
1061 Waggoner Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH · Church Daycare · Capacity: -999 children
St. Pius X is a religious facility in Reynoldsburg with mostly positive feedback from parents. The majority of reviews praise the teaching staff, curriculum offerings, and welcoming community atmosphere. However, there is one serious allegation of inappropriate teacher conduct that warrants attention.
Knowledgeable and kind teachersearly childhood language and computer instructionbeautiful facilitycordial staff - 7Rainbow Child Care Center4.08 score4.1(17)
8315 Taylor Woods Sw, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Rainbow Child Care Center receives consistently positive feedback from parents who praise the caring, experienced staff and family-like atmosphere. Parents highlight the center's developmental focus, strong communication with families, and attentive leadership. Children are reported to be happy, safe, and making significant educational progress.
Experienced and caring staff with long tenurestrong communication and monthly developmental updatesknowledgeable handling of special needs childreninvolved and responsive director - 8Little Scholars Learning Center II3.85 score3.7(5)
2731 Independence Village Ctr, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Little Scholars Learning Center II has mixed reviews. While some parents praise the owner Mr. Eric and report strong academic preparation, others have raised serious concerns about staff conduct, cleanliness, and classroom management practices.
Owner Mr. Eric is caring and invested in children's learningnew technology resources for educationchildren academically prepared for kindergartenreliable transportation to/from school - 9Sunshyne Early Learning Academy3.8 score3.6(5)
1713 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Sunshyne Early Learning Academy receives mixed reviews. Long-term clients praise the family-owned center for professional care, school preparation, and a positive learning environment. However, some prospective parents reported poor customer service experiences, particularly with female staff members, including lack of follow-up communication and unwelcoming behavior.
Family-ownedprofessional carestrong early learning skillsschool preparation - 10Learning Tree3.63 score3.4(8)
7751 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Learning Tree receives mixed reviews with strong praise from long-term families but serious concerns from recent visitors. Most satisfied parents highlight clean facilities, structured environment, caring staff, and happy children, while others report poor customer service, staff conduct issues, and accessibility problems.
Clean facilitystructured environmentcaring and professional staffchildren happy and enjoy attending
Rating Distribution
Based on 16 daycares with Google ratings in Reynoldsburg
What Parents Value Most
Top qualities mentioned across 257 reviews, analyzed by AI
Daycare Types Compared
Average ratings by facility type in Reynoldsburg, based on parent reviews
Best Rated Neighborhoods
Reynoldsburg zip codes ranked by average daycare rating
| Zip Code | Daycares | Avg. Rating | Top Rated | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43068 | 32 | 3.88 | 4 |
Facility Sizes
Capacity distribution of daycares in Reynoldsburg (50–107 children)
Small
up to 30 children
0
Medium
31–75 children
1
Large
76–150 children
5
Very Large
150+ children
0
Top Rated
Highest rated daycares in Reynoldsburg based on parent reviews
Reynoldsburg United Methodist Preschool
1636 Graham Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
Parents consistently praise Reynoldsburg United Methodist Preschool for its caring, dedicated teachers and positive learning environment. Children reportedly make significant academic and social progress while enjoying daily activities and developing enthusiasm for school. Families appreciate the curriculum, family engagement opportunities, and kindergarten preparation.
Messiah Christian School
1200 Waggoner Road, Reynoldsburg, OH
Messiah Christian School receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, with parents praising the caring, dedicated staff and strong educational programs. Most reviewers highlight the school's commitment to individual student needs and faith-based approach. However, one parent reported their child was discharged after only two weeks for behavioral concerns.
Capital Royal Child Care & Learning Center
1288 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
Parents consistently praise Capital Royal Child Care & Learning Center for its safe, nurturing environment and highly attentive staff. The facility is commended for strong communication, specialized care for children with allergies, and comprehensive daily activity monitoring via app. Children reportedly enjoy attending and show academic and social improvement.
A Child'S Place Learning Center
2010 Officeview Place, Reynoldsburg, OH
A Child's Place Learning Center receives mostly positive reviews praising the staff's care, educational focus, and child development outcomes. However, two negative reviews raise serious concerns about health/safety protocols, allergy management, staff conduct, and responsiveness to parent instructions.
Shining Stars Child Care
491 Lancaster Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH
Shining Stars Child Care receives overwhelmingly positive reviews praising the dedicated staff, caring director (Mrs. Shaton), and play-based educational approach. However, two negative reviews raise concerns about management practices, facility size, staffing decisions, and bus safety.
Rainbow Child Care Center
8315 Taylor Woods Sw, Reynoldsburg, OH
Rainbow Child Care Center receives consistently positive feedback from parents who praise the caring, experienced staff and family-like atmosphere. Parents highlight the center's developmental focus, strong communication with families, and attentive leadership. Children are reported to be happy, safe, and making significant educational progress.
Map
Daycare types in Reynoldsburg
Child Daycare & Preschools in Reynoldsburg, Ohio
There are 23 child daycare & preschools in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, making up 72% of the 32 total childcare facilities in the city. Below you'll find a complete directory to help you compare and choose the right daycare for your child.
Based on Google reviews, daycares in Reynoldsburg have an average rating of 3.88 out of 5 across 16 rated facilities, with 25% scoring 4.5 stars or higher. Before or After School Daycare facilities lead with an average of 4.6 stars. Our analysis covers 257 parent reviews. Parents in Reynoldsburg most frequently praise daycares for caring and professional staff, clean facility, and children enjoy attending.
When choosing a daycare in Reynoldsburg, consider visiting facilities in person, checking their licensing status, and asking about staff-to-child ratios, daily routines, and safety policies.
All Child Daycare & Preschools in Reynoldsburg
Showing 23 results
- Address
- 1314 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 751-8865
Parents consistently praise Reynoldsburg United Methodist Preschool for its caring, dedicated teachers and positive learning environment. Children reportedly make significant academic and social progress while enjoying daily activities and developing enthusiasm for school. Families appreciate the curriculum, family engagement opportunities, and kindergarten preparation.
- Address
- 1636 Graham Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 866-7216
Messiah Christian School receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, with parents praising the caring, dedicated staff and strong educational programs. Most reviewers highlight the school's commitment to individual student needs and faith-based approach. However, one parent reported their child was discharged after only two weeks for behavioral concerns.
- Address
- 1200 Waggoner Road, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 864-3506
Parents consistently praise Capital Royal Child Care & Learning Center for its safe, nurturing environment and highly attentive staff. The facility is commended for strong communication, specialized care for children with allergies, and comprehensive daily activity monitoring via app. Children reportedly enjoy attending and show academic and social improvement.
- Address
- 1288 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 866-5499
A Child's Place Learning Center receives mostly positive reviews praising the staff's care, educational focus, and child development outcomes. However, two negative reviews raise serious concerns about health/safety protocols, allergy management, staff conduct, and responsiveness to parent instructions.
- Address
- 2010 Officeview Place, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 868-5437
Shining Stars Child Care receives overwhelmingly positive reviews praising the dedicated staff, caring director (Mrs. Shaton), and play-based educational approach. However, two negative reviews raise concerns about management practices, facility size, staffing decisions, and bus safety.
- Address
- 491 Lancaster Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 868-3465
Rainbow Child Care Center receives consistently positive feedback from parents who praise the caring, experienced staff and family-like atmosphere. Parents highlight the center's developmental focus, strong communication with families, and attentive leadership. Children are reported to be happy, safe, and making significant educational progress.
- Address
- 8315 Taylor Woods Sw, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 575-5040
Little Scholars Learning Center II has mixed reviews. While some parents praise the owner Mr. Eric and report strong academic preparation, others have raised serious concerns about staff conduct, cleanliness, and classroom management practices.
- Address
- 2731 Independence Village Ctr, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 203-4774
Sunshyne Early Learning Academy receives mixed reviews. Long-term clients praise the family-owned center for professional care, school preparation, and a positive learning environment. However, some prospective parents reported poor customer service experiences, particularly with female staff members, including lack of follow-up communication and unwelcoming behavior.
- Address
- 1713 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 868-3950
Learning Tree receives mixed reviews with strong praise from long-term families but serious concerns from recent visitors. Most satisfied parents highlight clean facilities, structured environment, caring staff, and happy children, while others report poor customer service, staff conduct issues, and accessibility problems.
- Address
- 7751 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 861-8622
One reviewer questions the ethnic ownership of the center with a single critical comment. No specific operational details or positive experiences are provided in the available feedback.
- Address
- 1616 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 256-4224
One parent reports severe operational and safety issues, citing a dilapidated parking lot, unreliable hours, and a curriculum consisting entirely of television. The reviewer also alleges unprofessional conduct, including staff distraction by phones, inadequate hygiene practices such as sharing diapers, and a complete lack of potty training.
- Address
- 1733 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 869-6930
- Address
- 1357 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 759-8710
One parent highlights exceptional care and supportive resources, while two others report serious issues including unprofessional conduct, neglected hygiene, and unexplained injuries. The conflicting experiences range from high praise for the owner to strong warnings about staff behavior and safety protocols.
- Address
- 6535 E Livingston Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 577-0855
- Address
- 6549 E Livingston Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 625-1699
- Address
- 760 Rosehill Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 445-3750
- Address
- 10466 Taylor Rd Sw, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 445-3750
- Address
- 8200 Taylor Rd Sw, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 445-3750
Kiddie Academy of Reynoldsburg has consistently excellent reviews with all 5-star ratings. Parents praise the caring and professional staff, strong communication, educational programs, and safe environment. Children show intellectual growth and consistently enjoy attending.
- Address
- 6411 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 866-1422
KinderCare Learning Center #1159 in Reynoldsburg receives mixed reviews. Most parents praise the caring staff, educational programs, and long-term stability under current management, but a minority report serious concerns about supervision, staff behavior, and lack of administrative oversight from previous years.
- Address
- 6477 Centennial Drive, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 866-3750
KinderCare Learning Center #707 in Reynoldsburg receives perfect 5-star ratings from all reviewers, who praise the welcoming atmosphere, caring staff, and strong leadership under director Ms. Neka/Debi. Parents highlight excellent communication, cleanliness, engaging curriculum, and staff that treat children with genuine love and nurturing care.
- Address
- 6601 Bartlett Drive, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 866-4446
KinderCare Learning Center in Reynoldsburg receives mostly positive reviews praising staff care, communication, and safe environment, though two negative reviews raise serious concerns about treatment of children with developmental delays and billing practices.
- Address
- 6720 Tussing Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 868-9422
Parents consistently praise KinderCare Learning Center (also referred to as Taylor Woods KinderCare and Rainbow) in Reynoldsburg for its family-oriented atmosphere, caring and experienced staff, and strong educational focus. Directors and teachers are noted as responsive, involved, and particularly skilled at meeting individual children's needs, including special needs support. All 10 reviews awarded 5-star ratings, with parents expressing high satisfaction and long-term loyalty to the center.
- Address
- 8295 Taylor Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH
- Phone
- (614) 868-5267
Page 1 of 1· 23 results
Frequently asked questions
- Licensing status with Ohio's regulatory agency
- Staff-to-child ratios (requirements vary by age group in Ohio)
- Safety measures and cleanliness
- Daily routines and educational curriculum
- Parent reviews and ratings
- Location and hours that fit your schedule
- Child Daycare & Preschools — 23 facilities
- Church Daycare — 1 facilities
- Before or After School Daycare — 8 facilities