Best Church Daycare in Columbus, OH
Compare 21 church daycare in Columbus. Average rating: 4.29/5 stars. See top 10 ranked daycares, compare by type, and find the right childcare for your family.
Columbus, Ohio at a glance
- Programs
- 21
- Avg rating
- 4.29/5
- Parent reviews
- 2,364
- Top rated (4.5+)
- 142
Columbus has 21 licensed church daycare with 2,364 parent reviews averaging 4.29/5.142 are top-rated with 4.5+ stars — 53% of rated programs, well above average.The highest-rated options cluster around 43221 (avg 4.9 stars), while 43224 has the largest selection (36 programs).Start with our top-10 ranked list below or filter by philosophy.
Top 10 Best Rated Daycares in Columbus
Ranked using a weighted score that combines Google rating with the number of parent reviews — daycares with more reviews rank higher than those with a high rating but few reviews. Last updated: March 2026.
- 1Balanced Family Academy4.8 score5(20)
5150 Reed Rd, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Balanced Family Academy receives unanimous 5-star ratings from parents who praise the exceptional care, communication, and nurturing environment. Parents consistently highlight staff dedication, individualized attention to children, and peace of mind regarding their child's safety and development.
Excellent staff and teacher qualityregular communication with parentsindividualized child caresafe and clean facility - 2Balanced Family Academy Clubhouse4.8 score5(20)
1717 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Balanced Family Academy Clubhouse receives perfect 5/5 ratings from parents who praise exceptional staff care, strong communication, and a welcoming community environment. Parents consistently report feeling confident in their children's safety, development, and well-being at the facility.
Caring and nurturing staffexcellent communication and daily updatesindividual attention to each childclean facility - 3Little Dreamers Big Believers4.8 score5(20)
1347 West Fifth Avenue, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Parents consistently praise Balanced Family Academy (BFA) for exceptional staff who are caring, attentive, and communicative. First-time parents particularly appreciate the daily updates via the CareDay app and visible emotional security their children display. The facility offers quality meals, engaging activities, and a welcoming environment that makes parents feel confident leaving their children in capable hands.
Caring and attentive teachersdaily photo and text updates via CareDay appfresh homemade meals providedclean and well-organized facilities - 4Meadow Park Children'S Center4.8 score5(20)
2425 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: 186 children
Meadow Park Children's Center receives perfect 5/5 ratings from parents who praise the caring, experienced staff, enriching curriculum centered on play-based learning, and strong communication. Parents highlight the stable environment created by long-tenured teachers, diverse activities, and welcoming community atmosphere.
Experienced and caring staff with high retention rates (10+ years)play-based learning approachvariety of activities (artscience - 5Clintonville Crc Kids Club4.72 score4.9(20)
48 East North Broadway, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Clintonville CRC Kids Club receives universal praise from community members who describe it as a valuable resource offering food pantry services, support programs, and assistance to those in need. Staff and volunteers are consistently highlighted as friendly, helpful, and passionate about serving the community.
Friendly and helpful staffFresh produce and quality pantry itemsMultiple programs and support servicesWelcoming to all community members - 6Clintonville Crc Kids Club 24.72 score4.9(20)
7 W Henderson Road, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
CLINTONVILLE CRC KIDS CLUB 2 is a community resource center with exceptional staff and programming that serves diverse populations including families in need, seniors, and those experiencing food insecurity. Parents and community members consistently praise the friendly, passionate staff, fresh produce pantry offerings, and comprehensive support services available to the community.
Friendly and helpful stafffresh produce and quality pantry itemswelcoming environm - 7Clintonville Crc Kids Club 34.72 score4.9(20)
35 Oakland Park Ave., Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
This facility appears to be a community resource center rather than a traditional daycare, offering pantry services and community support programs. Parents consistently praise the friendly, passionate staff and the quality of fresh produce and assistance provided. Multiple reviewers highlight the organization's significant positive impact on individuals and families in need.
Friendly and helpful stafffresh produce qualitywelcoming environmentcomprehensive commu - 8Mary'S Little Lamb Child Interactive Learning Academy4.72 score4.9(20)
1800 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: -999 children
Parents consistently praise Mary's Little Lamb as an exceptional daycare with outstanding leadership under Ms. Tiffany. Reviews highlight the clean, well-organized facility, caring staff who treat children like family, engaging educational activities, and strong community involvement. Parents report feeling confident leaving their children in this program's care.
Clean facilityprofessional staffpersonalized attention to each childengaging activities and field trips - 9Jolly Tots Too!4.72 score4.9(20)
5511 N. Hamilton Road, Columbus, OH · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: 152 children
Jolly Tots Too! receives universal praise from parents across all reviews. Parents consistently highlight the caring, experienced staff, small teacher-to-child ratios, on-site nurse, and nurturing environment that supports children's growth from infancy through Pre-K. Families report feeling confident in the quality of care and describe the center as a loving community where children thrive.
Caring and experienced staffsmall teacher-to-child ratioson-site nurseclean and bright classrooms - 10Our Lady Of Bethlehem4.71 score5(12)
4567 Olentangy River Road, Columbus, OH · Church Daycare · Capacity: -999 children
Our Lady of Bethlehem is a highly regarded religious daycare facility in Columbus, Ohio with universally positive reviews. Parents consistently praise the caring staff, strong academic curriculum, spiritual guidance, and nurturing environment that supports children's development across multiple domains.
Caring and responsive teachersstrong curriculumsmall class sizesindividual attention
Rating Distribution
Based on 268 daycares with Google ratings in Columbus
What Parents Value Most
Top qualities mentioned across 2,364 reviews, analyzed by AI
Daycare Types Compared
Average ratings by facility type in Columbus, based on parent reviews
Best Rated Neighborhoods
Columbus zip codes ranked by average daycare rating
| Zip Code | Daycares | Avg. Rating | Top Rated | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43221 | 7 | 4.9 | 5 | |
| 43220 | 19 | 4.75 | 9 | |
| 43214 | 19 | 4.75 | 9 | |
| 43240 | 6 | 4.7 | 2 | |
| 43235 | 17 | 4.7 | 3 | |
| 43201 | 8 | 4.64 | 3 | |
| 43215 | 16 | 4.63 | 7 | |
| 43209 | 16 | 4.62 | 5 | |
| 43212 | 8 | 4.56 | 3 | |
| 43224 | 36 | 4.35 | 12 |
Facility Sizes
Capacity distribution of daycares in Columbus (12–312 children)
Small
up to 30 children
8
Medium
31–75 children
64
Large
76–150 children
64
Very Large
150+ children
11
Top Rated
Highest rated daycares in Columbus based on parent reviews
Our Lady Of Bethlehem
4567 Olentangy River Road, Columbus, OH
Our Lady of Bethlehem is a highly regarded religious daycare facility in Columbus, Ohio with universally positive reviews. Parents consistently praise the caring staff, strong academic curriculum, spiritual guidance, and nurturing environment that supports children's development across multiple domains.
Olentangy Church Child Care Center
2040- W. Henderson Road, Columbus, OH
Parents consistently praise Olentangy Church Child Care Center (now called Just North Christian Childcare) for its caring, professional staff and engaging educational environment. The facility is noted for its Christian atmosphere, creative activities, low teacher turnover, individualized attention, and affordability. Children are reported to be excited about attending and well-prepared for school.
St Anthony'S Extended Care
1300 Urban Dr, Columbus, OH
St. Anthony's Extended Care is a religious facility in Columbus, Ohio with a 4.7/5 Google rating. However, the available reviews appear to be for the church/parish itself rather than the daycare center, praising its welcoming community, spiritual services, and community support. Note: The facility is reportedly shutting down.
First Community Church Preschool
1320 Cambridge Boulevard, Columbus, OH
Reviews praise First Community Church Preschool as a welcoming, community-focused facility with excellent staff and services. Parents highlight the warm atmosphere, quality care, and additional community support including food pantry services. The church is noted for its organized operations and inclusive approach to families.
Polaris Christian Academy Early Learning Center
1250 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH
One parent highlights the welcoming atmosphere and engaging programs for their children, including staff appreciation and activities like Rise and Shine. Another visitor notes the church's active community stewardship and family-friendly environment during a child's event. A third reviewer appreciates the spiritual guidance and warm welcome experienced during a visit. No specific complaints about the childcare aspect were mentioned.
St Cecilia
440 Norton Rd, Columbus, OH
One parent notes their child enjoys attending preschool three days a week, while another describes the institution as a great private school with enduring values.
Map
Daycare types in Columbus
Browse by type in Columbus
Church Daycare in Columbus, Ohio
There are 21 church daycare in Columbus, Ohio, making up 4% of the 480 total childcare facilities in the city. Below you'll find a complete directory to help you compare and choose the right daycare for your child.
Based on Google reviews, daycares in Columbus have an average rating of 4.29 out of 5 across 268 rated facilities, with 53% scoring 4.5 stars or higher. Church Daycare facilities lead with an average of 4.85 stars. Our analysis covers 2,364 parent reviews. Parents in Columbus most frequently praise daycares for clean facility, safe environment, and children excited to attend.
When choosing a daycare in Columbus, consider visiting facilities in person, checking their licensing status, and asking about staff-to-child ratios, daily routines, and safety policies.
All Church Daycare in Columbus
Showing 21 results
Parents consistently praise Olentangy Church Child Care Center (now called Just North Christian Childcare) for its caring, professional staff and engaging educational environment. The facility is noted for its Christian atmosphere, creative activities, low teacher turnover, individualized attention, and affordability. Children are reported to be excited about attending and well-prepared for school.
- Address
- 2040- W. Henderson Road, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 459-9383
One parent highlights the welcoming atmosphere and engaging programs for their children, including staff appreciation and activities like Rise and Shine. Another visitor notes the church's active community stewardship and family-friendly environment during a child's event. A third reviewer appreciates the spiritual guidance and warm welcome experienced during a visit. No specific complaints about the childcare aspect were mentioned.
- Address
- 1250 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 436-1117
One parent notes their child enjoys attending preschool three days a week, while another describes the institution as a great private school with enduring values.
- Address
- 440 Norton Rd, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 878-3555
Our Lady of Bethlehem is a highly regarded religious daycare facility in Columbus, Ohio with universally positive reviews. Parents consistently praise the caring staff, strong academic curriculum, spiritual guidance, and nurturing environment that supports children's development across multiple domains.
- Address
- 4567 Olentangy River Road, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 459-8285
One parent describes the staff at this church-based program as great people doing great work. While the rating is high, there is limited feedback available to draw broader conclusions about the facility's operations or environment.
- Address
- 1230 Oakland Park, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 262-9756
St. Anthony's Extended Care is a religious facility in Columbus, Ohio with a 4.7/5 Google rating. However, the available reviews appear to be for the church/parish itself rather than the daycare center, praising its welcoming community, spiritual services, and community support. Note: The facility is reportedly shutting down.
- Address
- 1300 Urban Dr, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 885-4252
Parents highlight the caring staff and effective kindergarten preparation, noting that the program successfully combines learning with affection. The reviews emphasize a strong sense of community and spiritual growth, with one parent describing the church family as welcoming and focused on living for God. No specific complaints about the childcare operations were mentioned.
- Address
- 4581 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 410-5861
Reviews praise First Community Church Preschool as a welcoming, community-focused facility with excellent staff and services. Parents highlight the warm atmosphere, quality care, and additional community support including food pantry services. The church is noted for its organized operations and inclusive approach to families.
- Address
- 1320 Cambridge Boulevard, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 488-0681
- Address
- 123 Granville Street, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 627-1233
- Address
- 2774 Calumet St, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 261-8136
- Address
- 4382 Duchene Ln, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 861-0475
- Address
- 440 E North Broadway St, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- NOT AVAILABLE
- Address
- 1965 Gladstone Ave, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- NOT AVAILABLE
- Address
- 504 S Gould Rd, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 235-1396
- Address
- 933 Hamlet St, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 291-8601
- Address
- 2940 Parkside Rd, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 279-9935
- Address
- 672 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 433-5307
- Address
- 3880 Reed Rd, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- NOT AVAILABLE
All reviews are 5-star ratings praising the church's Bible-focused teachings, welcoming community, and emphasis on personal spiritual growth. Reviewers highlight deep friendships, supportive small groups, and transformative experiences. Some note the church requires high commitment and engagement.
- Address
- 1390 Community Park Dr, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 823-6540
One parent describes the Church of the Redeemer United Methodist Preschool as a great preschool with friendly and caring teachers.
- Address
- 235 Mcnaughten Road, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 861-7271
NOTE: These reviews are not from daycare parents but from church visitors, community members, and program participants. Bethel United Methodist Church in Columbus receives consistent praise for its welcoming atmosphere, community programs, and facility quality.
- Address
- 1220 Bethel Road, Columbus, OH
- Phone
- (614) 451-1117
Page 1 of 1· 21 results
Frequently asked questions
- Licensing status with Ohio's regulatory agency
- Staff-to-child ratios (requirements vary by age group in Ohio)
- Safety measures and cleanliness
- Daily routines and educational curriculum
- Parent reviews and ratings
- Location and hours that fit your schedule
- Child Daycare & Preschools — 364 facilities
- Headstart Programs — 21 facilities
- Church Daycare — 21 facilities
- Before or After School Daycare — 74 facilities