Children at daycare

Best Before or After School Daycare in New Haven, IN

Compare 1 before or after school daycare in New Haven. Average rating: 3.87/5 stars. See top 10 ranked daycares, compare by type, and find the right childcare for your family.

New Haven, Indiana at a glance

Programs
1
Avg rating
3.87/5
Parent reviews
20
Top rated (4.5+)
1

New Haven has 1 licensed before or after school daycare with 20 parent reviews averaging 3.87/5.Browse all options below to find the right fit for your family.

Top 10 Best Rated Daycares in New Haven

Ranked using a weighted score that combines Google rating with the number of parent reviews — daycares with more reviews rank higher than those with a high rating but few reviews. Last updated: March 2026.

  1. 1
    St. John'S Childcare
    4.2 score
    4.4(5)

    204 Rufus Street, New Haven, IN · Church Daycare · Capacity: -999 children

    St. John's Childcare receives mostly positive feedback from parents who appreciate the tight-knit community atmosphere and principal Mr. Coyle's personal engagement with families. Parents highlight the challenging academic curriculum and quality care. One parent gave a 1-star rating without elaboration.

    Welcoming communityknowledgeable principal who knows families by namegenuine carechallenging academic curriculum
  2. 2
    The Teaching Tree Nh
    2.84 score
    2.2(9)

    810 State Rd 930 E, New Haven, IN · Child Daycare & Preschools · Capacity: 84 children

    THE TEACHING TREE NH has extremely polarized reviews with stark contrasts. Positive reviews praise staff members like Missy and Ms. Amaya for creating a safe, structured learning environment with good communication and caring attention to children. Negative reviews cite serious concerns including staff negligence resulting in child injury, lack of supervision, unprofessional and rude behavior, state violations, and overall poor management.

    Safe and structured learning environmentkind and caring staffgood parent communication and check-insprofessional application process

Rating Distribution

Based on 3 daycares with Google ratings in New Haven

4.5 - 5.0
1
4.0 - 4.4
1
3.0 - 3.9
0
Below 3
1

Daycare Types Compared

Average ratings by facility type in New Haven, based on parent reviews

Child Daycare & Preschools

3.6avg rating
2 daycares · 2 rated

Before or After School Daycare

No ratings yet
1 daycares

Church Daycare

4.4avg rating
1 daycares · 1 rated

Facility Sizes

Capacity distribution of daycares in New Haven (84–84 children)

Small

up to 30 children

0

Medium

31–75 children

0

Large

76–150 children

1

Very Large

150+ children

0

Map

Daycare types in New Haven

Child Daycare & Preschools 2Church Daycare 1Before or After School Daycare 1

Before or After School Daycare in New Haven, Indiana

There are 1 before or after school daycare in New Haven, Indiana, making up 25% of the 4 total childcare facilities in the city. Below you'll find a complete directory to help you compare and choose the right daycare for your child.

Based on Google reviews, daycares in New Haven have an average rating of 3.87 out of 5 across 3 rated facilities, with 33% scoring 4.5 stars or higher. Church Daycare facilities lead with an average of 4.4 stars. Our analysis covers 20 parent reviews.

When choosing a daycare in New Haven, consider visiting facilities in person, checking their licensing status, and asking about staff-to-child ratios, daily routines, and safety policies.

All Before or After School Daycare in New Haven

Showing 1 results

New Haven United Methodist Preschool
Before or After School Daycare

New Haven United Methodist Preschool receives mostly positive feedback from parents, with five 5-star reviews praising the caring staff and religious messaging. One parent gave a 1-star rating with no explanation, and another gave a 4-star rating without detail.

caring and gracious staffweekly pastoral messagesage-appropriate messaging
Address
630 Lincoln Highway East, New Haven, IN
Phone
(260) 749-9565

Page 1 of 1· 1 results

Frequently asked questions

There are 1 before or after school daycares in New Haven, Indiana, out of 4 total childcare facilities in the city. Browse our directory to compare options and find the right fit for your child.
Based on parent reviews, daycares in New Haven have an average Google rating of 3.87 out of 5 across 3 rated facilities. About 33% of rated daycares score 4.5 stars or higher.
When choosing a daycare in New Haven, consider visiting facilities in person and checking:
  • Licensing status with Indiana's regulatory agency
  • Staff-to-child ratios (requirements vary by age group in Indiana)
  • Safety measures and cleanliness
  • Daily routines and educational curriculum
  • Parent reviews and ratings
  • Location and hours that fit your schedule
New Haven offers several types of childcare facilities:
  • Child Daycare & Preschools — 2 facilities
  • Church Daycare — 1 facilities
  • Before or After School Daycare — 1 facilities
Each type serves different needs — center-based facilities typically offer structured programs, while head start programs are federally funded for low-income families.
Daycare costs in Indiana typically range from $200 to $400 per week for full-time care, depending on the child's age, facility type, and location within the state. Infant care tends to be more expensive due to lower staff-to-child ratio requirements. Contact individual facilities in New Haven for current pricing.
Yes, daycare centers in New Haven must be licensed by Indiana's childcare licensing agency. Licensed facilities are required to meet standards for safety, health, staff qualifications, and staff-to-child ratios. You can verify a facility's license status through your state's licensing database.